top of page

The Lieutenant Rowan Mindset

Apr 20, 2024
3 min read





In 1898, the Spanish–American War began in the aftermath of the internal explosion of USS Maine in Havana Harbor in Cuba. This led to United States intervention in the Cuban War of Independence.


Just before the war started, President McKinley desperately needed to communicate with General Garcia, the leader of the Cuban insurgency. 


The challenge was daunting: Nobody knew where to find General Garcia in Cuba!


One of McKinley's advisors believed in the capabilities of a young man, First Lieutenant Andrew S. Rowan…who was promptly summoned and tasked with the critical mission of finding General Garcia. 


Once given his orders, Rowan enthusiastically accepted the responsibility, saluted the President, and set off for Cuba to accomplish his mission. 


Within three weeks, he triumphantly returned to the White House, reporting, "Sir, your message has been delivered."




This story is from ‘A Message to Garcia,’ a widely distributed essay, with millions of copies sold. It was written by Elbert Hubbard in 1899. 


This popular story is about the value of individual initiative, resilience, grit and conscientiousness in one's work. 


Traits that you would want in an employee and business partner. 


One of my business partners has been sharing this story with advisors for decades.


The essay contrasts Rowan's self-driven determination and effort against…to quote the essay… "the imbecility of the average man—the inability or unwillingness to concentrate on a thing and do it".


Does this sound like how the youth of today are described?


How about the average worker?


Of course it does.


But it was written 125 years ago which should serve as evidence that this dynamic in the workforce has always existed.


In considering the implications of this story for hiring individuals today, it is evident that these principles are timeless yet need thoughtful application.


But…should a ‘Lieutenant Rowan Mindset’ filter be applied to everyone on your team or in your organization? 


I have just reached the age where I now have business partners younger than I am and employees who aged young enough to be my children. 


My personal privilege has been having a Father, Grandfathers and mentors who instilled the ‘Lieutenant Rowan Mindset’ in me.


I was taught and shown by example that it is imperative to outwork everyone and always try to ‘deliver the message to Garcia.’ 


My grandfather, Paul Joyce, was a tough WWII Bomber Pilot. He told me at the beginning of my career: “If you are known as someone who can’t be out worked, you will always have a job.

That was ingrained in me from a young age.


But, was that the right guidance? 


Young employees entering the workforce often exhibit enthusiasm, but may lack the experience and guidance that is needed to have the ‘Lieutenant Rowan Mindset.


More specifically, they may not have had the mentorship to develop the mindset.


There are people on your team and in your organization that just have not had the right mentorship to unlock the power of this mindset!


By encouraging them to take initiative and by guiding them in the nuances of navigating workplace challenges you are encouraging them to build the skills necessary to succeed in their career and life.


Some people just need the right mentor. 



Here is a framework for thinking about your team and business partners. 


  1. Do they have the ‘Lieutenant Rowan Mindset?

  2. Do they have the capability and desire to develop the ‘Lieutenant Rowan Mindset’ and they just need to be nourished? 

  3. Do they not have the ‘Lieutenant Rowan Mindset’ and show no signs of wanting to develop it?


It is ok to not have the ‘Lieutenant Rowan Mindset’ It is just important that you both understand the limitations they will have and find the right role for them.


I hope you enjoyed this Saturday Note!




Comments


3.png
2864 Johnson Ferry Rd; Suite 200
Marietta, GA 30062
  • X

© 2026 Resilient Advisor

Resilient Advisor is a business consulting, coaching, and educational media company owned and operated by Jay Coulter. Resilient Advisor is a separate business from Titleist Asset Management, LLC and Titleist Capital, LLC. Resilient Advisor is not a registered investment adviser or broker dealer and does not provide investment advisory, securities brokerage, legal, tax, or accounting services.

Jay Coulter serves as Chief Executive Officer and Chief Investment Strategist of Titleist Asset Management, LLC and is an investment adviser representative of the firm. Any investment advisory services provided by Jay Coulter, and any related investment advisory client relationships, are offered and maintained exclusively through Titleist Asset Management, LLC under a separate written advisory agreement. Visiting this website, subscribing to its content, participating in a Resilient Advisor coaching program, or communicating with Resilient Advisor does not create an investment advisory relationship with Jay Coulter or Titleist Asset Management.

Titleist Asset Management, LLC is registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission as an investment adviser. Registration with the SEC does not imply a particular level of skill, training, or endorsement by the SEC. Titleist Capital, LLC, an affiliate of Titleist Asset Management, is registered with the SEC as a broker dealer and is a member of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority and the Securities Investor Protection Corporation.

The information provided through this website, including articles, podcasts, videos, newsletters, tools, presentations, and coaching materials, is intended solely for general educational and business consulting purposes. Discussions of investment management, financial planning, markets, securities, or financial strategies should not be interpreted as individualized investment advice or as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security. Nothing on this website constitutes an offer or solicitation for investment advisory or brokerage services.

Information presented on this website is based on sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy, completeness, and timeliness are not guaranteed. Opinions and information may change without notice. Any references to past results, business outcomes, or investment performance do not guarantee future results.

Titleist Asset Management and Resilient Advisor do not provide legal or tax advice. Please consult an attorney, tax professional, or other appropriately qualified professional regarding your individual circumstances.

bottom of page